Here’s a slide excerpt from my talk,
Old Weymouth—A New Look. The Tuckahoe River’s head pond was a spung just west of the “new” Doughtys Tavern rebuilt after the realignment of the Tuckahoe (Cape) trail in ~1801 (solid yellow line). The original tavern, I believe, resided where the earlier Tuckahoe trail (dashed yellow line) was “improved from a beaten path” and intersected the earlier course of the Bears trail (dashed teal line).
Hopkins (1873) not only shows the Tuckahoe’s head pond, but extends a wet corridor (a cripple?) northward to the Punch Bowl, a perfectly round spung across from the Hensel farm. The Tuckahoe head, the Bears head, the Punch Bowl, and Clarks ponds have all long faded from living memory.
Hopkins, G.M., 1873: Combined Atlas of the State of New Jersey and the City of Newark. Newark, NJ: G.M. Hopkins & Co. 120 pp.
S-M