Hey - that was cool, thanks for posting. Lots of memories....
We had one of the older (but not original) log cabins on Tabernacle Road. It was interesting how they built them back then, since they were only intended to be summer homes. In many cases, they just put some stones in each corner, laid logs across them and built the home with no real foundation. Ours was originally like that, but was later improved somewhat. Had to go into the crawlspace a couple times and it was like crawling under a car! Very rustic inside, with a huge stone fireplace in the main room, vaulted ceiling, all finished with split cedar logs.
Owned that place from 1997-2002, and was glad to get out with a nice profit when I did. In 1999 the Settler's Inn burned down, will never forget that day. The town just didn't seem the same afterwards.
Then in 2004 the big flood came through and really took a toll on Medford Lakes. It was a real mess after that. I was living on Atsion Rd in Medford then, and very fortunate to have a home on high ground that didn't experience anything but a wet spot on the rug.
Can you believe it’s been a decade since that frightning Monday evening in July 2004, when torrential downpours hit this area, causing major floods, a host of dam failures and
www.southjerseylocalnews.com
You can see some of the lakes were still emtpy in 2006. IIRC, somebody was killed driving near Aetna lake when the dam burst.
https://online.boydsmaps.com/#17/39.86341/-74.80692/njgin2006
Thinking back a little farther, I remember "discovering" Medford Lakes back in 1993 when I was still living in PA, just out for a drive. I just loved the whole atmosphere there, so we started looking at real estate. Found a really cool original log cabin right on the lake with a dock - perfect for the canoe carnival. They were asking a little too much, but the agent was sure they would take less. Looked at the schools, and the middle school left a lot to be desired. Then there was the issue of having only a tiny yard while we had a big dog. So we passed on that - for good reasons - but I always regretted it. By 1997 our daughter was in high school, and Shawnee was great, so we finally moved there. One of my daughter's best friends was the granddaughter (maybe great-granddaughter?) of the Medford Lakes founder, Leon Todd. My lawyer was the Mayor of Medford Lakes.
On a darker note, talking to a friend who had been in the area a long time, she said that for many years (until the 1970's perhaps?) Jewish people were not welcome there.