Thanks everyone!
46er, about those rainbows, it wasn't for lack of trying! We did go out twice for rainbows and came up short. Once was a colder day in November, we tested out the new waders at Pequest/Lockwood and -nothing-, then we tried again more recently and we threw San Juan worms, zebra midges, and a few others at them and, again, got the skunk.
He's getting some confidence with the rod now. Once the seal broke and he got the pickerel, he did end up getting some sunnies and some nice crappie with the wooly buggers and San Juans. We'll be working our way back up to trout soon, but part of me is really looking forward to a little warmer weather and getting him on some smallies or at least some rock bass/small LMB that inhabit local streams. I'll keep you posted if we get on any trout. Wish us luck!