Trapped in Snow: GPS Blamed

devilstoy

Explorer
Nov 21, 2008
355
1
45
lindenwold
sometimes its just lack common sense , if it looks that bad and coverd with snow why would you even try to continue on ??? im sure on a nice summer day that road wouldve been fine
 

Kevinhooa

Explorer
Mar 12, 2008
332
25
41
Hammonton, NJ.
www.flickr.com
That's insane. With so many newer devices to tell people how to do things, it's no wonder some people are doing dumber and dumber things without thinking first. Whatever happened to good judgement and a paper map?
 

turtle

Explorer
Feb 4, 2009
653
214
a village...in the pines
Kevin,
You just said it: The dumb people don't think and let the devices tell them how to do things. Consequently they drive us insane by not using good judgement and being too lazy to learn how to use a paper map.
(I think I rearranged the words in your statement to respond to you!)

You do realize that in order to use a map, you must have knowledge of basic math skills and know how to read, right? :eng101: :)
This would explain why they can't read a sign when they reach their destination either! :rolleyes:

Honest mistakes are easy to remedy and a pleasure to assist......I use the rest as a cheap form of entertainment.
 

ecampbell

Piney
Jan 2, 2003
2,889
1,029
We have Onstar and I am constantly dissapointed in the routes it picks. It has no local knowledge and frankly makes dumb decisions. I make my on routes using Google Earth coordinates and enter them into my 60CS. That also ensures that I've paid attention to my trip.
 

LARGO

Piney
Sep 7, 2005
1,553
134
54
Pestletown
Seems Oregon is a definite No-No for GPS use. There should be a disclaimer on the box.
"If you live in Oregon, feel free to toss this in the nearest body of water or use it as a lighted coaster for your drink at night. If you are doing any traveling, roadmaps are cheaper than this thing. Now go away."

Aside from common sense like you all say, I carefully pour over arial maps and love checking roads online then getting down low like you can on Bing and looking at the actual areas for landmarks. Works great! I've talked my wife in from some wierd spots on the phone while she got crossed up. Told me where she was and I just use the phone and talk here right to whatever intersection, turn, road, etc. Cool.
My father-in-law couldn't believe once on the phone as I was telling him what he was going to see at every turn and what ramps went where he needed to be.

This summer, I went on a trip to Sylvan Lake in N.Y., I looked at images, I checked routes, I used satellite, even printed some routes, and guess what I brought with.
My dad's trusty Road Atlas Book. It'll never fail ya if you bother to open it up and use it. Go figure.

I've seen the GPS in cars work pretty good and real good sometimes but I'm not putting any stock in them on a trip. Good preperation for a ride is key, not something that looks like my kid's Nintendo D.S. but with a map on it.

g.
 

Boyd

Administrator
Staff member
Site Administrator
Jul 31, 2004
9,826
3,007
Ben's Branch, Stephen Creek
My father-in-law couldn't believe once on the phone as I was telling him what he was going to see at every turn and what ramps went where he needed to be.

You should start a 1-900-CALL-LARGO service for lost people. :) I had to do this for my daughter a couple times when she first started driving also. Problem is, people don't learn how to do things (like read maps) for themselves when somebody else does it for them....

I've been fascinated by maps ever since I was a little kid and always had a collection of them. A GPS receiver is just a tool, it isn't good or bad in and of itself. Its usefulness is related to the quality of map data that it contains of course. In the end, the responsibility of knowing where you are and how to get somewhere falls directly on the driver of the car. A stupid person with a GPS is still a stupid person.

Most of the time I use gps as an electronic map that I can scroll around and zoom in and out of. I have the real USGS 24k quads for several states and NJ2007 aerials for the pines on a Magellan 1700 running custom software. It has a nice 7" screen and shows exactly where I am on the map. This goes way beyond what I could do with paper maps - especially while driving!

But it's no different from the application of computers to other fields. For example, in my work I stopped drafting with paper and pencils in 1994 and switched to CAD. Before then, I had a big file cabinet plus lots of tubes filled with rolled up drawings and could never find things. Now I have every drawing I've ever done since 1994 on my laptop where it's accessible in a few seconds.
 

46er

Piney
Mar 24, 2004
8,837
2,144
Coastal NJ
A GPS receiver is just a tool, it isn't good or bad in and of itself. Its usefulness is related to the quality of map data that it contains of course. In the end, the responsibility of knowing where you are and how to get somewhere falls directly on the driver of the car. A stupid person with a GPS is still a stupid person.

Right on point. GPS and maps are one in the same, a tool, one on paper, the other electonically stored. On a road trip I use both, favoring the Delorme Atlas for the paper version. I have one for every state I've been in. For me, much of the fun of a road trip is the planning that goes into it. Right now I'm planning our trip to Glacier NP this July.

And a stupid person with a map can get in just as much trouble as a stupid person with a GPS.
 
Top