I'm with you Bob it is fun to pretend (i didn't vote). I've always found the Jersey or Leeds Devil myth very interesting. I think one of the greatest mysteries of the pine barrens for me is the exact origin of the legend. I do tend to lead toward the deformed child theory. Most of the other theories just don't seem to hold water. The other possibility is that it was just made up for the sheer amusement of it, but it seems unlikely it would have grown as it did. Maybe within a small community (Leeds point perhaps) it was used within the community as a means of controlling/scaring childern in order to keep them out of the woods. Word spread to town to town and so on.
Whatever it is, it is a very unique myth. It was not a natural oddity like bigfoot or Lock Ness, but not a ghost story either. Something inbetween. As for all the sightings, well, there are about a million explainations for that. From pranks and lies, to mistaken identity, to overactive imaginations. The myth itself is such a mystery why do we even need the monster in the flesh. One thing that has always interested me is how the nature of the devil has changed over the years. The earlier stories have it eating childern, ripping off the tops of trees, and causing people to lock themselves in at night. Later stories have it squacking at people and, well, standing there. Based off the early stories, and considering the deformed child theory, that child might have been one scary dude.
As long as scout troops and organizations of that nature keep camping in the pine barrens the legend will live on. I think that is a good thing.
Jeff