I have both canoes and kayaks and enjoy them both. A kayak is certainly easier to paddle, especially in open water. If either boat will do on a given outing, I'll chose the kayak over the canoe. But I sometimes use my canoe for duck hunting. There's no way I can fit myself, a labrador, decoys, gun, and misc. gear in my kayak, not to mention another hunter. Fishing from a kayak presents less problems, but I never liked sitting so low in the water while fishing. Likewise, while you can use a kayak for camping if you are a minimalist, canoes allow for much more gear. Then there are my frequent exits, at a moments notice, whenever I see a plant I want to examine more closely or perhaps a historical feature. Kayaks are just enough more inconvenient to get in and out of that I might pass up something I might otherwise hop out of my canoe to check out.
Both boat types have their uses and I think that if you are going to use your boat for a variety of activities, don't try to find something that will be a jack of all trades and master of none. Used boats are easy enough to find at a decent price and will outlast the next half dozen cars or trucks you'll own. There's little reason for not owning both types if you can foresee their need!
Both boat types have their uses and I think that if you are going to use your boat for a variety of activities, don't try to find something that will be a jack of all trades and master of none. Used boats are easy enough to find at a decent price and will outlast the next half dozen cars or trucks you'll own. There's little reason for not owning both types if you can foresee their need!