Totally believable, the water temps are perfect and especially with Burgess and Schoelkopf agreeing on it. The medical waste that was dumped off LBI last week and washed up on the beaches was probably like a dinner bell for the toothy critters. Certainly not a sand shark, you can see the teeths incision marks in the bite photo. When I had the boat, 2 of our favorite spots for inland shark fishing were inside Great Egg and Barngat inlets, its amazing what you don't see that's under the surface.....