I too got chased at Menantico colony, they actually caught us and took down our names and addresses but declined to press charges so long as we promised not to come back. We were cornered by several people in pickup trucks and had no way to escape. I have several pictures from inside those buildings, but I won't post them due to the illegality. This was around 2003. I now try to avoid situations like that, if you have even a minor criminal record you normally have to disclose it on job applications and such. Very creepy in there, and most of the buildings are wide open, if not from the front doors then through the fire escapes.. I'm surprised they haven't been demolished just to eliminate the safety hazard. Locally, there was a good deal of interest in the site when WeirdNJ published an article on it, around that same time frame.
Those woods to the northeast of the colony, and near the broken dam, are full of dirtbike trails but extremely hard to navigate. You often can see a clearing, or hear cars, but there's an impenetrable swamp blocking the way, and you have to go around it, all the while losing your bearings. The time we got lost, we entered near Panther and Trento, making for the broken dam, but never made it. We were in there for a good six hours, it was May, so the sun stayed up pretty late, but we realized we had a real problem and may not make it out before complete darkness. We could hear cars and thought we could even see the edge of the woods but each time we tried to bypass some deep water, it seemed like it got us no closer. We discussed stopping for the night and making some kind of shelter in case it got cold. We decided to walk until it became too dark to continue and by chance wound up at the gas line. I was maybe 15 years old, this was around 2001 or so. I know it sounds rediculous but to this day, that tiny parcel of woods had me the most lost I have ever been.
The rattletrap was a big dirtbike/atv spot in those days, and we used to play paintball back there. The boundaries of the game were the entrance road in the north, and the deer fence in the south.