Agreed John. There is no perfect boot for the woods.
However, if you plan on going cross country through all types of terrain in one day, then the boot chosen has to be the boot needed to get through the worst anticipated condition. That's why I wear the Lacrosse 18", as do most other people I hunt or hike with, including my dainty little wife. With a little dexterity and a few blow-downs across a stream, there isn't much you can't negotiate in 18" boots.
For me, with the proper sock and insert they are very comfortable and I can and do wear them all day.
The Maine Hunting Shoe by Bean is reaching a ridiculous and unwarranted peak of popularity right now with Hipsters. Most of those boots will only see a little slush on the sidewalk in their lifetime. Someone gave me an unused pair last year and I gave them away immediately without ever wearing them. They are far too limited in their applications, in my opinion. If I were to wear a Maine Hunting Shoe it would be for bird hunting in wet grass and that's it. Having to rely on leather uppers that require waterproofing treatments and a sewn leather to rubber seam is not something I want to rely upon or own.