In the first post of this thread Ben said he made the change to be "more feature rich, future proof, and sustainable." Considering all the hard work he does, and the expense he incurs running this site, I think we need to trust him on that. Happy Easter Ben, and thanks for all that you do for us.
Thanks. It certainly wasn't my intention to ruffle any feathers or rain on anybody's parade with the upgrade to the new forum software. The fact of the matter is that I was pretty much done with running vBulletin, which in my opinion is just a mess right now and I bought a Xenforo license as soon as they went on sale to test and play around with. I looked at it many months ago and it wasn't ready for prime time yet, but over those few months they've really done a lot of amazing work and I felt comfortable going live with them.
Integration with social media - whether people like it or not - is the future. I have a feeling that eventually web based forums such as this will go the way of the BBS from the 1980s and 1990s. Going with a product that ties into social media will, I believe, help future proof the site. The nice thing is that you're not forced to have a Twitter or Facebook account, or even participate in any sort of social media site, to use the site. Do I use cues from those other sites now? Yes. Avatars here now work in a very Facebook-like way. But again, if you don't want one - you don't need one. At the end of the day it's just a picture that shows up next to your posts.
Regarding the redesign of the layout - which seems to have cause the greatest amount of concern - it was a decision that I made consciously to have the layout of the forums match the layout of the front page (
http://www.njpinebarrens.com) which never took up the entire width of the screen like the old forums did. So yes, now the forums all fit within a 960 pixel wide box and you see the background with the trees on the side. If you run your browser in full screen on a 24 to 27 inch monitor set to a high resolution you're going to be unhappy. But really, a lot of other websites are going to look like garbage as well.
The design of a website is a purely subjective thing mixed with some technical considerations thrown in for good measure. I can make a site that will look really good for giant size monitors, but will look like crap on small ones. I can make a site that looks great on small monitors but looks like crap on larger ones. I feel like I struck a balance between the two and ultimately obtained my objective of making the forums look like the front page. I know that things need some tweaks here and there and I'm working on them (heck, today was a beautiful day and I was inside working on the site all day - trust me, I'd rather have been outside doing something fun.)
I appreciate the feedback that everyone has given me so far. To the folks that don't like the new design I just ask you to give it a few days and see if it grows on you. Trust me, I know how hard change is.