Have you tried on any Maine Hunting Shoes (MHS)Ben ? Another reason I gave away the ones that were given to me is that they had almost no arch support and felt hard and flat.
I don't want to be a di#k (can't help it) but there are some pretty negative reviews on the MHS for that same reason some of the hunting journals too.
Upland Journal Forum: "If you're walking on level ground in non slippery conditions and don't need any arch support, they'll probably be perfect for you."
In response to the above: "There's a ringing endorsement. Sounds like they'd be good for loafing around the cabin after the hunt."
24 Hour Campfire website forum :As much as I like the nostalgia of these.....On dry leaves they are quite slippery, your feet will sweat where the rubber part is, they are not for cold weather, the tread is not deep enough for good traction, ankle support is just not there (I need that), your feet will feel rough or rocky terrain. The good.... they are light, are pretty good in the rain if you water proof the uppers, you can feel the ground underneath your foot when stalking. I see these as a spring turkey or fall "walk in the woods" type boot or maybe fall bird hunting like walking the fields for pheasants if you don't need the ankle support for steep terrain. Too many other better choices these days. As I like traditional stuff I really wanted to like them but they weren't for me when the hunting gets serious or for cold weather. Ended up wearing mine around the yard and on rainy days.
I'll go away now.
Well I think the MHS is a different animal than the Bean boot. The Bean boot has a metal shank for arch support whereas the MHS does not. Otherwise they're pretty similar.
Now the "not for cold weather" bit bothers me, since my main goal was to have these to wear when there was deep snow on the ground.
Don't be so hard on yourself, Ben always likes the straight skinny. But, for what Ben is using them for, he should be fine. I use the same ones I've had 25 years for shoveling snow around the house and quick drives during snow season.
If only I could do the straight skinny. I can do a slim straight, or a slim taper, but no skinny. I have to work on that.